the-midnight-paper

PaperTitle

Authors:

Conference

Keywords

Overview

What is the paper about?

…

What are the contributions?

…

What is the take home message?

…

Significance and originality

…

Significance and originality

Are the ideas novel/original?

…

Are the contributions significant?

…

Soundness

Are the ideas presented technically correct?

…

Are the proofs accurate?

…

Are the algorithms correct?

…

Evaluation

Are the ideas/algorithms empirically or theoretically evaluated?

…

If some assumptions are made, are they realistic?

…

Is scalability demonstrated?

…

Related Work

Is the paper properly situated with respect to related work?

…

Is there a brief survey of related work?

…

Do the authors explain similarities and differences with previous work?

…

Readibility

Is the paper well structured?

Does the abstract properly and accurately summarize the paper?

…

Do the introduction and conclusion clearly explain the contributions and the take home message?

…

Is the flow of ideas easy to follow?

…

Is the paper well written?

Are all the technical terms and abbreviations explained?

…

Are there important grammatical errors?

…

Are there a lot of typos?

…